The Modernist Reformer

The last personality of the Modernist is the Reformer. Pope St. Pius X spends only one section on this personality, and it is basically just a list of everything that the Modernists want to reform:

  • Philosophy, especially in the seminaries
    • Scholastic philosophy ought to be abandoned as too absolutist, in contrast to modern philosophy which is better suited to the times.
  • Theology
    • Rational theology should be based on modern philosophy, and postive theology on the history of dogma.
  • History
    • Any history taught must rely on modernist principles discussed earlier.
  • Dogmas and their evolution are to be harmonized with science and history.
    • “In the Catechism no dogmas are to be inserted except those that have been reformed and are within the capacity of the people.”
  • Worship:
    • The number of external devotions is to be reduced.
    • Steps must be taken to prevent their further increase.
  • Church governance:
    • All branches, but especially disciplinary and dogmatic departments, should be made more democratic.
    • “a share in ecclesiastical government should therefore be given to the lower ranks of the clergy and even to the laity and authority which is too much concentrated should be decentralized.”
    • The Roman Congregations and the index and the Holy Office must be modified.
  • When engaging with the political world and society, the Church “must adapt itself to them in order to penetrate them with its spirit”
  • In the area of morals, the active virtues are more important than the passive, and should be encouraged more.
  • Clergy should return to their primitive humility and poverty, and in ideas and action should admit the principles of Modernism.
    • Some desire the suppression of clerical celibacy.

If you change all this, what do you have left?

*This post is part of a series on Pascendi Dominici Gregis. Click here for more posts on Pascendi and Modernism.*